Monday, February 10, 2014

Analysis on Ariel's Journal


Ariel chose to do a journal on the Ted talk we watched on Mike Rowe. She chose too analyze the quote "If I'm wrong so often." Her analysis included her thoughts on that even though things seem to be straightforward in right/wrong ways that may not be. I am choosing to talk about this quote as well because I think it relates well to people's lives today. Often we as Americans are so quick to judge. We see something, and don’t think twice before coming to a quick assumption or conclusion. For instance, walking past a homeless person on the street. Immediately one may assume that the person doesn’t work or that they are a lazy person in general. We wouldn’t consider thinking about the fact that the person may have worked hard their entire life and recently lost everything in a fire and was diagnosed with cancer. We are wired to overestimate disposition and underestimate the situation. Throughout the Ted talk, Mike presented on situations that he has experienced. In the course of his job he encounters many situations with people who have jobs that the typical American would consider horrible. He goes on to talk about how these people are some of the happiest people he has met, and how they are completely content with their job even though someone else may not be. The point that I feel the quote from this TED talk is trying to point out is that we as American’s need to stop and take time to think about the situations that others are in. We need to be able to take a step back and realize that we may have initially been wrong and reevaluate our opinions.

1 comment:

  1. Claire, I really like how you related Mike Rowe's reaction to us citizens today and also how you pointed out we are more likely to overestimate their disposition rather than seriously consider their situation. By doing this and not considering their situation, it is also like not caring about the person. Your homeless person example is great in showing this. It often seems today that some of the stereotypes other people have about how Americans act (such as our laziness or that we only seeking personal gain) are often proved true from the way we act to others who we do not know. I think it is important for us to take a step back and give up time out of our day to help one another. I think it would be very beneficial for all Americans, and people in general, to have the same realization that Mike had “I’m wrong so often”.

    ReplyDelete